How policy continues to fail South Africans

To curb inflation, the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) has raised interest rates by 4.75% to a 14-year high of 8.25%. Following the various shocks our economy faced throughout Covid-19, inflation breached the upper limit of the Sarb’s target range for 13 consecutive months, leading to the central bank tightening monetary policy since November 2021.

While inflation has since eased – to an annualised 5.4% in September 2023 – rates remain at their highest since 2009, prompting many to criticise the Sarb for its approach. Some even believe the biggest obstacle to growth and job creation in the short term is the Sarb’s obsession with inflation targeting; we tend to agree.

Traditionally, real interest rates around 2% are best for long-term sustainable growth, which means that there is a lot of room for the Sarb to cut interest rates and support struggling South African consumers.

The central bank’s scope to lower borrowing costs may also improve as its counterpart in the US, the Federal Reserve, potentially nears the end of its rate hiking cycle. More and more analysts are beginning to forecast that US rate cuts are on the horizon. Although analyst predictions vary widely, they all seem to agree that the US will most likely start cutting interest rates in the second half of 2024 and will do so rapidly.

Oil impact

Import inflation, especially that of oil, has been a favourite scapegoat of the Sarb, which likes to cite a depreciating rand, elevated global oil prices, or even bad weather as credible reasons why the medium-term outlook of inflation does not look rosy enough to cut interest rates. Although the rand will most likely appreciate, the oil price should remain unchanged during 2024. The string of weak macroeconomic data, including a slowing global economy and rising US crude stockpiles, will likely keep prices in check.

Oil headed for a fourth weekly loss after sinking into a bear market when supplies remained healthy, and stockpiles rose to offset attempts by the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC+) to keep price declines in check. Oil price declines have also been supported by the apparent vanishing of an Israel-Hamas war risk premium, as fears about oil production have so far not materialised.

Read:
Oil collapses into bear market as robust supply pressures OPEC+
Oil ticks higher after two-day swing as OPEC+ countdown begins

OPEC+ will however probably do its best to keep the oil price between $80 and $100 during 2024. But even if it does, this will mean that the oil price will remain largely unchanged and, therefore, there will be no real risk to inflation in South Africa.

Global oil demand will most likely also keep the oil price in check. Figures from China, the world’s largest importer of crude, showed that refiners cut daily processing rates in October as apparent oil demand decreased from a month earlier. Meanwhile, US unemployment benefits rose to the highest level in almost two years, signalling a slowdown in the world’s biggest crude consumer.

What’s behind SA’s deterioration?

A scathing report was published by Harvard University’s Growth Lab, whose research aims to help policymakers understand how to accelerate economic growth.

The report identified two main reasons for SA’s deterioration: the poor capacity of the state, and the government’s inability to address the spatial exclusion it inherited from apartheid.

Unfortunately, the researchers found that the policies put in place by the ruling party since then have only worsened the impact of spatial exclusion.

Read:
10 years later: Has the NDP disappointed?
Few jobs in SA for (black) people who didn’t finish school

A common thread throughout the research is how the government’s poor economic policy fails to yield desired outcomes, such as job creation and economic growth. One of these economic policies is the stringent preferential procurement regulations, which have, at best, supported entrepreneurs from specific ethnic groups but have not led to inclusive growth.

Another main growth impediment is labour policies, the frontrunner being black economic empowerment, which reduced overall economic growth in SA.

The researchers concluded that SA’s trajectory is not one of growth and inclusion but rather stagnation and exclusion.

Listen to this Moneyweb@Midday podcast with Jeremy Maggs:

You can also listen to this podcast on iono.fm here.

Download the free LiSTN audio app on Google Play, Apple or here.

Dr Francois Stofberg is senior economist at Efficient Wealth and managing director of Efficient Private Clients.